Japan Sets Up Space Policy Commission

The revolution- or perhaps evolution- is at hand! After a week of waiting by this author about actually who will be in charge of Japan’s new era of space policy making, the names have finally been published.

On Friday, the Cabinet Office, now in charge of Japan’s new space policy structure following the June 20 passing of the law that allowed the Cabinet Office to take control of Japanese space policy, published the names of the all-important Space Policy Commission (宇宙政策委員会).

Prime Minister Yoshihiko Noda flanked by State Minister for Space Motohisa Furukawa and Takeo Kawamura, who started the whole process of reforming Japan’s space policy, unveils the official Kanban for the Space Strategy Office

The Space Policy Commission consists of seven members that will function as the highest consultative body to the space and prime minister on program authorization, budget and schedule, according to according to Takafumi Matsui, Emeritus Professor at The University of Tokyo, and chief architect of the establishment of the new office, who is also a member.

The  Commission is to be chaired by Yoshiyuki Kasai, former chairman of Central Japan Railway Company, and fellow key members of the  “Mk.II” Experts Committee of the Strategic Headquarters for Space Policy (SHSP) which was built on the original May 2010 Matsui Report.

Joining the Commission  are Hiroshi Yamakawa, Secretary-General of the SHSP,   Shinichi Nakasuka, a University of Tokyo scientist and the father of Japan’s university-led microsatellite program, and Setusko Aoki, Professor of Policy Management at Keio University, a leading expert on space law, and a key member of the LDP-era SHSP that got so close to developing Japan’s Space Activities Act in 2009.

The move comes rapidly after the Cabinet Office  July 12 set up the Space Strategy Office, the new executive body that will assume control of the nation’s space programs, headed by current State Minister for Space Development Motohisa Furukawa.

The Space Strategy Office replaces a mix of institutions that controlled various parts of Japan’s space program, most notably the Space Activities Commission (SAC), a former committee in the Ministry of Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology (MEXT), that formerly controlled the budget and program planning of the Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency (JAXA), Japan’s main space development agency that absorbs about 60% of the nation’s national space budget.

The Space Strategy Office’s formal establishment comes just weeks after the Upper House of Japan’s Diet June 20 passed a raft of legislation to set up the office, abolish SAC, and change JAXA’s founding law to allow it to develop military space programs in line with international norms under the 1967 Outer Space Treaty, among other things, Matsui said July 13.

Matsui said the Space Strategy Office will become functional by the end of July in time for taking control of Japan’s annual space budget request.

“Everything is as I, we planned. We have to get it functional by in time for the budget, negotiations with the Ministry of Finance,” Matsui said.

FINALLY! Japan Passes Law Permitting Military Space Development

Here is the text of the quick story I put up last Friday for Defense News. For background on this story Japan Space Law: Now Mid-May, or When?

I’ll have a more more commentary on this later in the week. Well it’s three years late, but finally it’s gone through after considerable struggles. I’ll have something of a more detailed picture on the whole thing out later this year for Space Policy.

However talking to Kazuto Suzuki and Norihio Sakamoto over the past few weeks I have been struck by the differences of opinion on the upcoming speed with which the 宇宙戦略室 (Space Strategy Office) is going to be able to act. Sakamoto believes that the much-needed Space Activities Act, which is much needed to promote commercialization in J-space could come even within this year. Suzuki believes the law isn’t really a priority and not needed. Listening to an SHSP presentaiton on the issue earlier this year at a conference to establish the Keio Advanced Research Center for Space Law, the message seems mixed.

It has been pointed out that essentially the three-year battle to wrest control of space policy and execution from MEXT was de facto won last year when the SHSP under Katase effectively grabbed the budget negotiations with the MOF away from MEXT. You can see the effect immediately in that the much prized JAXA-MEXT flagship Hayabusa-2 program got its huge budget request stomped.

But the new law is far more than window dressing, as I will go on to explain in subsequent posts.

Tokyo — The Upper House of Japan’s Diet June 20 passed legislation that shifts control of the nation’s space policy and budget, and opens the door to military space development programs with an emphasis on space-based missile early warning.

The raft of legislation, based on the Bill to Amend the Law of Establishment of the Cabinet Office that was sent to the Diet on Feb. 14, enables the Prime Minister’s Cabinet Office to take control of the planning and budgeting of Japan’s government space program. It also removes an article in a prior law governing the Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency (JAXA), the nation’s equivalent to NASA, which had restricted JAXA’s ability to pursue military space programs.

Prior to the legislation, JAXA had been de facto controlled by the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology (MEXT), and was overseen by a MEXT committee called the Space Activities Commission (SAC), leading to criticisms of regulatory capture.

At the same time, JAXA’s space development has been restricted to an extremely narrow “peaceful purposes only” policy, which meant the agency was unable to develop specifically military space programs.

The new legislation enables the Cabinet Office to set up a Space Strategy Office, headed by the prime minister, which will have the ultimate say on all policy and budget decisions. It will be supported by a consultative Space Policy Commission of five to seven academics and independent observers.

The legislation also scraps MEXT’s control of JAXA and abolishes SAC, said Kazuto Suzuki, associate professor of international political economy at the Public Policy School of Hokkaido University.

Japan’s space development has been hampered by the peaceful-purposes-only restriction, and by what many outside MEXT see as programs focused too much on technological development for its own sake, leading to expensive launch systems and satellites that serve little practical purpose for the nation, Suzuki said.

The passing of the law ends a process that began nearly a decade ago by politicians looking for ways to leverage Japan’s space development programs and technologies for security purposes, to bolster the nation’s defenses in the face of increased tensions in East Asia.

On top of an increasingly confident China, Japan faces a potentially belligerent and unstable North Korea just across the Sea of Japan. Since 1998, North Korea has consistently flouted and broken promises, norms and international laws in developing and testing nuclear weapons and missiles.

JAXA will now be permitted to develop space programs in line with international norms, which are governed by the Outer Space Treaty of 1967. The treaty allows military space development, but not the deployment of weapons of mass destruction in orbit.

As the Cabinet Office, the Ministry of Defense and the Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry (METI) will all have a form of “joint control” over JAXA, the space agency will gradually move away from its purely scientific, non-military role, said analysts and experts involved with drawing up the legislation. Under the new arrangement, each ministry will be able to propose its own space programs.

METI, for example, is interested in promoting dual-use Earth observation and reconnaissance satellites and an air-launch space access system, according to the ministry.

Suzuki said there also is strong bipartisan political support for Japan to develop and launch its own missile early-warning system to support the nation’s small fleet of Aegis destroyers for upper-tier defense, and its PAC-3 systems for lower-tier defense.

The Cabinet Office also will take direct control of the budget and program development of Japan’s regional GPS system, called the Quasi-Zenith Satellite System.

More immediately, the Cabinet Office is likely to set up the Space Strategy Office and Space Policy Commission as early as July 1, said Norihiro Sakamoto, a research fellow at The Tokyo Foundation, a think tank based here.

The Space Strategy Office will quickly move to draft new laws and policies to shift Japan’s space focus away from purely research and development programs to a more national, security-orientated approach that encourages the industrialization and commercialization of Japan’s space industry.

In particular, Japan needs to draw up a comprehensive space law, a “Space Activities Act,” which will provide a legal framework for privately funded space initiatives, and a five-year space plan to run through the second half of the decade.

Japan Space Law: Now Mid-May, or When?

What is this man doing?

News from the Strategic Headquarters for Space Policy (SHSP, 内閣官房宇宙開発戦略本部事務局) just in is that the Law to establish Japan’s new space structure, in which the Prime Minister’s Cabinet Office will start to try to wrest control of Japan’s space programs from the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology (MEXT), will now be delayed until mid-May.

According to SHSP director Mikio Aoki, the bill, which was submitted to Japan’s lower house, the House of Representatives on Feb. 14 was originally to have been debated and passed by the end of March.  It was then rescheduled for April 20. However, the DPJ administration is bogged down in other issues, most notably Prime Minister’ Noda’s discussions with opposition leaders about the DPJ’s plans to raise the consumption tax from April 2014. on which Noda has said he has staked his political life.

Noda is widely suspected of planning to dissolve the Lower House for a snap election if the Diet rejects the taxation bill. If this happens, then Japan faces another long and frustrating wait to enact the Basic Space Law of 2008.

The space bill, Cabinet Office Restructuring and Reform Law (内閣府設置法等の一部を改正する法律(閣議決定)),  is designed to fundamentally restructure the control of Japan’s space program and remove the restriction on the nation’s main space agency, the Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency (JAXA) from developing military space programs. It is designed to enable the Prime Minister’s Cabinet Office to set up a 30-member Space Strategy Office (宇宙戦略室) that is headed by the Japanese Prime Minister while scrapping the Space Activities Commission, which currently controls JAXA. The Strategy Office  will assume control of all of Japan’s space planning, program and budget control, including that of JAXA through a new Strategic Space Committee set up in the Office, also chaired by the Prime Minister, said Takafumi Matsui, Emeritus Professor of Tokyo University and chairman of the advisory committee that proposed the law. For more on this, please see: Bill to Establish the 内閣府宇宙戦略室 (Space Strategy Office) sent to the Diet.

The Bill should have been drawn up and enacted within two years of the original Basic Law but was stalled by the election of the DPJ in 2009 and the opposition of MEXT, with the SHSP only managing to find a workable compromise this February. For some details of this, please see How will the SHSP’s Next-Gen Space Plan Unfold? The architects of the Bill had tied it to the General Space Activities budget,  which should have been passed March 31; and if the delay stretches much beyond May, this could impact Japan’s space policy making for yet another year.

Bill to Establish the 内閣府宇宙戦略室 (Space Strategy Office) sent to the Diet.

For a treat, how about looking at what a real Japanese bill looks like. Story below!

Rather surprisingly early, the bill (properly called 内閣府設置法等の一部を改正する法律案) to enact the pertinent points of the 2008 Basic Law was sent to the Diet on February 14, with optimists considering that as it is tied to this year’s General Space Activities Budget request, it will be passed. My sources in the SHSP put the chances at 50/50 and Matsui Sensei is hopeful- tying the reforms to (a) the QZSS project and (b) the budget request, were critical parts of the Expert’s Committee in the SHSP last year to finally get the business sorted. Very practical, for a very tricky project that has gone through three years of twists and turns.

Understandably the Japanese media focused on a summary of the main points; for example here the Sankei, while the Mainichi also thought it prudent to add a 解説 (explanation) for the public. The Yomiuri and Nikkei also managed to capture this critical event for the future of Asia’s space development and competition. I have a much more detailed academic article coming out later in the year, but here is a summary of something I filed on the bill.

Space Bill Submitted to Japanese Diet

A bill to fundamentally restructure the control of Japan’s space program and remove the restriction on the nation’s main space agency, the Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency (JAXA) from developing military space programs, was submitted to Japan’s lower house, the House of Representatives, Feb. 14.

The Cabinet Office Restructuring and Reform Law will enable the Prime Minister’s Cabinet Office to set up a Space Strategy Office that is headed by the Japanese Prime Minister while scrapping the Space Activities Commission, which currently controls JAXA. The Strategy Office  will assume control of all of Japan’s space planning, program and budget control, including that of JAXA through a new Strategic Space Committee set up in the Office, also chaired by the Prime Minister, said Takafumi Matsui, Emeritus Professor of Tokyo University and chairman of the advisory committee that proposed the law.

A key part of the bill changes JAXA’s Law of 2003, when the agency was established, which, in Article 4 (Objectives of the Agency), contains the stipulation that JAXA’s space programs be “for peaceful purposes only.” The new bill brings JAXA’s law into line with the Outer Space Treaty of 1967, which allows for the nonagressive military use of space, and Japan’s Space Basic Law Article 14: “The state shall take the necessary measures to promote space development and use to endure international peace and security as well as to contribute to the national security of Japan.”

Matsui said Feb. 17 that the bill fulfills a critical stipulation of the Space Basic Law of 2008, which mandated that policy, programmatic and budgeting control of Japan’s space programs, which are funded by a number of ministries, be assumed by the Cabinet Office. Currently JAXA accounts for about 60% of Japan’s space budget, and is controlled by SAC; both are part of the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology (MEXT). JAXA’s budget and programs will now also be controlled by the Cabinet Office’s Space Strategy Office, he said.

Matsui said that the bill should come into law by the end of this fiscal year, March 31, so the Cabinet Office can immediately start setting up the new office. Typically bills approved by the lower house in Japan are rubber stamped by the upper house, the House of Councilors, he said.

Here is the Yomiuri’s coverage:

Japan Moves To Relax Restrictions on Military Space Development

Here is a story that I did just before the law was sent to the Diet on Feb 14 (see later article) about (finally, after three years!) the Cabinet Office moving to enact the Basic Law of 2008 and move to take (partial- just how this may spin out, see later article!) control of Japan’s space development, specifically with controlling Japan’s regional GPS system, the QZSS…

Like most media, I had to follow the headline, but have reserved deeper analysis for my research, to be published later this year…of course none of this is a surprise to readers of “In Defense of Japan“….

Space Quarterly 2: A Battle Looms for Japan’s Space Program

Ironically, just as my second piece in Space Quarterly came out on December 1, the SHSP’s Expert Committee (宇宙開発戦略専門調査会) chaired by MHI Chairman Kazuo Tsukuda had just (November 30) come out with a pre-final version of the compromises reached between the Cabinet and MEXT over the makeup and powers of the 宇宙戦略室 (Space Strategy Office) to be set up in the Cabinet Office!

Japan Aims To Build Own GPS by 2020

This is the next critical breakthrough when the Mk.2 SHSP Experts Committee finally managed to get the all-important 閣議決定 (kakugi kettei, Cabinet decision) for Japan to push ahead and develop the QZSS system, and a critical part of the Matsui plan to use the QZSS program as a way to set a precedent for the Cabinet Office to take power and budget away from MEXT in order to take control of the troubled program. Remember back in June, MEXT had steadfastly opposed the idea of loosing 20-30% of its budget to the Cabinet Office to run the QZSS program. What has changed? Leadership by the Noda Administration. Yoshihiko Noda, as I’ve said in past posts, has been a strong supporter of space development and led the DPJ’s committee on supporting the bipartisan Basic Law of 2008.

Before any legal changes to be announced to enable the Cabinet Office to take control of the QZSS, there are other still thorny issues about who is going to share how much power in the reform of Japan’s space administration. As the Experts Committee had set itself an August deadline to resolve the issue, the MEXT opposition is still strong. However, my sources in the SHSP are confident that the issues an be sorted out by year-end.

Higher Hopes for Yoshihiko Noda

I think it’s fair to say I wouldn’t be alone in believing the Hatoyama administration managed to twist triumph into disaster within a year, undoing much if not all of the goodwill and hopes of a Japan weary and frustrated with 50 years of unbroken LDP administration, and perhaps not too cynically expecting something different from the DPJ. Given that a good proportion of the DPJ is made up of former renegade LDP politicians mixed with former socialists and social democrats, it was always going to take a strong leader able to manipulate the levers of power in Kasumigaseki if the DPJ was to move forward at all. Japan, instead got Hatoyama, who managed to wreck himself on the shoals of the 2006 basing agreement. Whatever the merits and demerits of Naoto Kan, his administration was overwhelmed by the Great East Japan Earthquake and ongoing Fukushima Dai-ichi Nuclear Power Plant Nightmare.

All this is well known and not news for Japan watchers, but the reason why I decided to write up some hopes and expectations of the deliberately unglamorous Yoshihiko Noda (for some reason called by some hacks as Yoshiko Noda?) was that, as the son of a former paratrooper and not a fading political dynasty or a former……social/ anti-establishment reformer with an axe to grind, Noda is the nearest thing to a moderate, behind-the-scenes colorless but able political mover in the classic uninspiring but able LDP lever puller that the DPJ had to offer at the time. More importantly, Noda was a strong supporter of the DPJ’s bipartisan team supporting the Basic Law of 2008 and practical enough not to be wedded to the DJP’s fantastical Uchu Cho (Space Agency). So all the indications were that Noda, bringing back Seiji Maehara and able to cut deals with the DPJ would finally be able to move the SHSP to completing its work to enact the Basic Law… and so it proved. Here, meanwhile, was the Defense News Article of the time.

Profile: Hiroshi Yamakawa

Here is a story in Space News I forgot to put up at the time- a profile with the all-important Hiroshi Yamakawa, the DPJ’s new appointee as DG of the SHSP. As earlier posts have shown, it was not for lack of trying that Yamakawa’s schedule was delayed. But even at the time, regardless of Dr. Yamakawa’s subsequent success, it was obvious that with Katase-san also at the helm the SHSP was going to pull it off and get the Basic Law enacted sooner or later.

SHSP Decision on New Space Agency Delayed a Month

2011年8月10日

The decision on the shape of the new space agency (origially called the 宇宙庁) in the original Matsui Plan has been stalled again by last-minute haggling as MEXT mounts a last-ditch battle to stop ceeding budget and programmatic authority to the Prime Minister’s Cabinet Office, according to Takafumi Matsui, architect of the plan, in an interview yesterday (Tuesday August 9). It was quite spooky to interview Matsui Sensei in the offices of the IIPS in Toranomon knowing that a major bureaucratic battle between MEXT, METI and the CO was taking place a scant 500 meters or so away in Kasumigaseki proper- a battle completely ignored by the mainstream press but covered in Japan’s gutsy shukanzasshi (weeklies).

As I pointed out last week in How will the SHSP’s Next-Gen Space Plan Unfold? August 8 was supposed to be Change You Can Believe In day when the SHSP was to finalize the transfer of power of authority of the QZSS system development to the CO along with the budgetary powers to complete it, largely at the expense of MEXT. According to Matsui Sensei, MEXT is going down fighting and it is unclear whether the deal will go through.

As I pointed out last time,   June 30′s  政府の宇宙開発利用体制の在り方について(案) represents a compromise- originally the 宇宙庁 was to have complete control of space policy and budget, but according to Matsui Sensei, it represents a stealth-step in the right direction. If the plan works, then the CO will have seized control of Japan’s largest ever space infrastructure project, involving the building of a 7 or 8 satellite constellation of Michibiki satellites that will provide sub-1 meter positioning and emergency communications and as yet undisclosed (to be worked out- nothing sinister) functions.

For those of you familiar with the QZSS project, the CO taking charge is both a practical solution and a master stroke all at once, removing the in-fighting that has plagued the project for the best part of a decade and firmly putting the CO in charge of space national security and public infrastructure.

Meanwhile the General Space Activities budget looks like another year when the steps toward the doubling of the budget by 2020 look for the moment buried in the ruins of Tohoku and the melted down Fukushima Dai-ichi Units 1-3, with the DPJ trying to enforce a 30% cut in some science and technology fighting.